Right after the war, in 1995,
Bosnia-Herzegovina was connected to the Internet network via the university
line UTIC. Next year, in 1996, the postal service of Bosnia-Herzegovina started
providing Internet services. Already then a large number of conventional media
outlets in Bosnia-Herzegovina had Internet editions, and Internet sites of
their media were created for groups of people who had emigrated abroad from the
country. Professionally and technologically speaking, these web sites were up
to acceptable standards regarding use of information technology in Internet
journalism. Rapid development of New Media in our region resulted from dramatic
wartime and political circumstances since the Internet connected people in the
fastest, easiest and most efficient way, informing them about events on which
their destinies depended. People with political dominance over the media were
naturally inclined towards this because dissemination of information helped the
development and strengthening of their policies among the Bosnian-Herzegovinian
people even in the most remote parts of the world.
With regard to this, we must remember
the above-mentioned fact that at this early stage a large number of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian media outlets were present on the Internet, although
Bosnia-Herzegovina was known as the country with the smallest number of public media
domains in the world. There were four in total until the year 2000 because the
local network infrastructure could not satisfy the needs of users, due to which
services of Internet providers across Europe and the United States were used,
mostly in Florida and California. Meanwhile, although there are no exact
scientific studies on this issue, one can say that Bosnia-Herzegovina was one
of the leading countries in the world by the number of media outlets on the
Internet per capita. This paradox brings to mind another earlier, also very
important paradox of significance to the study of journalism in the world.
The appearance of mobile personal
computers with autonomous energy supply and compatible with desktop computers
enabled journalists to take their computers out into the field and send
digitalized items from there which were already laid out for the needs of
computerized newsrooms. This innovation was mostly used by sports reporters who
are tied to the field due to the nature of their work and who had to send
reports to their newsrooms at maximum speed. The first such major attraction
occurred during the 1984 Winter Olympic Games in Sarajevo when American and
Japanese journalists used laptops to write articles and then, via a modem,
directly connected them to the telephone network, while at the same time ready
articles entered their newsrooms’ computer memories on the other side of the
ocean.
This breakthrough enabled the
development of telematics, mutual adaptation of technology and tt connections. Computers could ‘talk’
to each other via telephone lines. This was accompanied by a paradox because
the problem were not intercontinental connections which were based on the
application of new technologies enabling enormous increase in capacities. The
main problem were local connections where development of technology and
investment limitations did not allow the capacities to grow together with the
needs. Connections in countries which are underdeveloped communication-wise are
still limiting the development of computer communications and this is also
happening in Bosnia-Herzegovina. These limitations especially hurt radio and
television stations which are striving to provide quality design of their
Internet sites.
RADIO
AND TELEVISION STATIONS ON THE INTERNET
Internet
Television
The New Media offer a high level of
convergence of information and communication technology. Their content is
convergent and can be readapted to a different infrastructure. Of particular
significance with regard to this is the linking of television and personal
computers because these media units are very similar. Digital television is
taking over a certain scope of functions of personal computers since Internet
service is built into the digital television system. It is interactive digital
television, not personal computers and the Internet, that is conquering the
space of the New Medium. It provides content receivers with new services
prepared for the television medium. The majority of information users find this
to be a more acceptable form of receiving contents and services than to be
receiving Internet services through web contents developed for personal
computers and reshaped for acceptance and interaction through the television
medium.
With regard to this, the basic
characteristics of performance of the New Media need to be pointed out. They
are:
-
interactivity
-
delivery on
request
-
delivery and
acceptance under the information consumer’s control
-
unrestricted
time of delivery and use
-
electronic
delivery of digitalized content.
The above characteristics differentiate
the New Media from traditional media such as radio and television and create
conditions for media operation where e-television has a dominant role.
It is estimated that 97 percent of
households in the world watch television program every day. This means that
millions of hours of TV program are received every day. E-television is based
on this foundation because the adding of functions of personal computers and
the Internet expands the space of information and media performance. This
creates a New Medium in the form of interactive, digital television which gives
information consumers access to different contents on the principle of
individual use of information contents. Users themselves can choose what, when and in what way they want to watch. E-television advances from a system
of broadcasting contents to a system of interactive selection of desired
contents at the chosen time and in the chosen place.
However, this advantage creates the
problem of recognizing the needs and interests of information consumers to a
much larger extent than in the case of classical television. Hence, an
Electronic Programming Guide – EPG must be delivered to information consumers
via the available information contents to provide the possibility of faster
and simpler identification of desired
contents from many different sources.
Browsing
the Television Program for Information
Television and video programs are
extremely abundant sources of information. Despite their dynamic nature, unlike
text and picture they lack interactivity needed to carry out successful
information search and browsing. By organizing their programs into searchable
digital libraries available via communication networks, large archives of
multimedia information are created and programs are opened which can be used
for selective searches over a long period of time.
Many systems were created over the past few years which have
produced outstanding results in this area, but we will restrict ourselves to
one of them, Pictorial Transcripts,
because it offers an example of media processing which can be used for
automatic generation of multimedia libraries of television programming. The
system gives particular attention to mechanisms needed to make efficient
searches of multimedia information in thousands of hours of television
programming.
Text
Processing
Textual presentation of information
enables non-pictorial information to be shown in compact form, which makes it
easier to search through textual data bases. What makes this type of search
easy are transcripts made for sound elements in the program by using automatic
speech recognition (ASR). Large vocabulary automatic speech recognizers (LVASR)
exist for specific domains, such as North
American Business News Task, which are able to transcribe speech during
active work with 90.5 percent precision. When we apply other tasks for which
language and acoustic models exist, we cannot just use them any way we want
because the error assessments could be considerably higher. Results received by
applying certain techniques in transcribing television programming are
therefore encouraging. Such transcripts have shown expected results in
searching and browsing through information. High error assessment is limited in
their case thanks to the use of certain automated transcripts that users use
directly.
Audio
Decoding
Whilst a combination of pictures
received by taking samples and linked with text ensures a more compact
presentation of information contained in a video program, audio is added to the
delivery of additional information to video (e.g. music, unuttered sound).
Audio components are essential when titled text is useless. We have an example
of high quality audio supply in the Transform Predictive wideband speech Coder
(TPC), which uses a compacted 7 kHz wide audio flow of 16 Kb/s. This ratio can
be reliable for picture and textual transmission via a telephone line which is
switched on with a 28.8 Kbs or stronger modem. Digitalization and compression
of audio signal is carried out in real time during the reception phase. Audio
signal is divided into component parts which have a time connection with the
other video segments.
Automated
Production of Hypermedia Documents
In the final stage, information
received by media processing is used for hypermedia in a video program in
Hypertext Markup Language (HTML) form. The HTML production process is guided by
pre-determined patterns created to be used for adapting various information.
Program segmentation to individual pages is basic for document size. Information
on the structure of visual information can be used for program segmentation
within a story. In these cases pictures of equal capabilities can be used to
locate limited stories, after which more important page segmentation is carried
out.
Search Engines and Browsers
The search prototype of the Pictorial Transcripts system contains
several thousand hours of video program for broadcasting. Efficient use of
large multimedia libraries depends on intelligent mechanisms used to carry out
selective information searches. This eliminates the need to organize program
into several different categories and having to get several information search
engines and browsers.
The Pictorial
Transcripts homepage contains program organization for television networks.
There are several different programs in it. Transcript offers HTML presentation
of information in a form that contains stylized pictures, text and icons to
initiate the running of accompanying audio. Therefore, Pictorial Transcripts Player representation enables real time
running of certain pictorial, textual or audio information using a striming player. This pictorial and audio presentation is useful for making
quick searches of program material in saved pictorial information, which
enables the user to quickly search through the entire program to find the
pictures he is interested in. Audio icons can be used to get additional
information about the program.
If we choose one of the television
stations offered on the homepage (CNN for example), we will get a list of
different programs for selective broadcasting. If we choose the latest program,
we will plug into a live broadcast. If we choose ‘previous programs,’ we will
get access to a program archive via an interactive calendar.
The system provides several search
engines and browsers which enable selective search and browsing through
material. Some search engines allow the user to select stored programs with
full text search. This interaction enables the user to specify one or a
combination of programs included in the search. The search string is specified
by the user feeding back information about the relevant video program to be
selectively searched.
A picture base search can be carried
out in the same way. In this case the user selects pictures and compares them
to other pictures in the program and then picks the most similar photographs.
Pictures are used as links to corresponding points in the program. This
possibility can be used for segmenting news programs in a story unit. For
example, for certain news programs, the beginning of a new story is always
linked to the central view of the person itself, whilst a small window shows
pictures related to the story. In other cases pictures of equal capabilities
can be used to locate the story margins.
Each video program is organized into
pages. Each page has navigation links to the previous, next or some other page
in the program such as the index page. The index page contains a selection of
pages using textual and pictorial indicators. A pictorial index contains a
collection of pictures and each represents the content of one page in the
transcript. Index pages allow the user to search through parts of program at a
certain time. This enables the use of a set of keywords and phrases singled out
during the linguistic processing stage in creating Pictorial Transcripts. Selection of one of these words or phrases
results in the creation of transcripts of specific keywords. A transcript of
specific keywords is created for efficient search through the entire program in
order to access relevant information on the selected keyword.
Television
Stations on the Web
RTV BiH www.rtvbih.bih
The site has a visually modest design. It offers the following sections: about
RTV BiH, news, sports, weather, marketing, contacts, mailing lists. The
homepage contains a selection of news of the day in textual form with links to
more extensive information. The site’s value are mailing lists: news, sports
news, TV program schedule, radio program schedule and weather forecast. Users
can register for a mailing list and they will receive regularly on their e-mail
addresses the contents that are prepared for the field they register for. It is
of particular note that this is the only web site of a public media outlet in
Bosnia-Herzegovina which has a separate web newsroom.
NTV HAYAT www.ntvhayat.com The site contains the
following sections in textual form: overview of shows, program schedule,
marketing, news and human interest pieces. Shows that can be watched live on
video are separated from the regular program. Of the shows that are offered for
watching, only one is informative, two are sports and the rest feature
entertainment and music contents. News is archived following a monthly
calendar. Searches can be carried out using keywords, but this is very poorly
organized.
JP RT RS Banja Luka www.rtrs-bl.com The site is visually
attractive. It contains textual information on this television company and a
selection of current news. It broadcasts an experimental Internet program.
TV BN Bijeljina www.rtv.rstel.net The site has modest
design. It does not broadcast an Internet program. The site only contains the
program schedule and reference to current programs.
TUZLA TELEVISION www.tvtuzla.net It does not broadcast its
own Internet program, but visitors can follow Radio Kameleon and Radio Slon
programs and watch two recorded video clips about Tuzla. It has banners.
RTV
Grad Sarajevo www.radiograd.delta.com.ba
Design of the site is modest. It contains basic information and contacts for
marketing services in the regular program. The possibility of listening to its
program via the Internet is limited to several chosen shows from the year
1997/98 stored in Real audio format.
RTV
Zavidovici www.geocities.com/rockbih/radio-zavidovici.htm
Design of the site is very poor. It does not have a real player for listening
to the program.
RTV Vikom Gradiska www.vicom-company.com The Vikom media
organization has a very serious approach to its web site design and
maintenance. Programming from Vikom studios in Derventa, Gradiska and Banja
Luka can be watched live on the Internet. Information is updated regularly in
textual form with links to other Web sites that visitors can use.
RTV Big Banja Luka www.big.banjaluka.net This Web site
provides its users with textual information. It does not broadcast its program
on the Internet.
RTV BN Bijeljina www.rtvbn.rstel.net It features a
textual program schedule and selection of news from the informative program. It
does not broadcast its program on the Internet.
ALTERNATIVNA TELEVIZIJA BANJA LUKA www.atvbl.com It features bilingual textual
content in Serbian and English. The homepage gives an overview of shows from
the program. Links lead to more comprehensive information on selected programs.
For example, the program Ukrstenica (Crossword
Puzzle) provides an overview of political events. The aim is to show how TV
stations in the former Yugoslavia view them, but it does not have links to
these television stations. It also brings a list and content analysis of the
talk show Nezvanicno (Unofficial).
News which is broadcast in the regular program is stored in Real Player format
and can be heard and watched.
In the previous years we had an
opportunity to see a much larger number of Bosnian-Herzegovinian television
stations on the Internet. In the meantime, many of them have lost interest in
Internet presentation. Among them are the following:
ZETEL Zenica www.zetel.net This private TV station used to
have a www site on the address www.bih.net.ba/-zetel.
A message has been there for more than a year now saying that the site has
moved to a new address. The old site was abandoned and a new one has not been
developed.
RTV Lukavac www.geocities.com Analysis of the site
over the past several years shows major oscillations. At the beginning we had
an almost useless site that was poorly visited. A new design was later made
which was in perfect harmony with the task to inform and with the existing
technical infrastructure. Particularly important in the design of the site was
networking with other media that provide media analyses of certain issues. The
new design resulted in a lot of visits to the site. As of recently the station
has been out of function and under development.
Radio
Stations on the Web
One hundred and seventy radio stations
operate in Bosnia-Herzegovina. They experienced the biggest expansion during
the time of Internet expansion in Bosnia-Herzegovina. Over the last year or two
their number has been reduced because many of them have not been maintaining
their Web editions.
Application of new information
technologies gives the radio a big opportunity to establish itself as a New
Medium by adapting to the New Age. To put it simply, if a radio station finds
itself on the Web, it is expected to have, in addition to the expected audio
segment, also something that would have been unbelievable until recently –
visuality. A journalist’s interview with a well-known singer will be
accompanied on air on the Web site by an appropriate video clip, animated
sequence or some other principle. This is an indication that a media symbiosis
is starting to develop, in which each individual medium will have a new,
multimedia component. (The earliest beginnings of media diversity in
presentation of information could be seen until a year ago on the Web site of
Radio Dobre Vibracije – Denmark, edited and prepared by young emigrants from
Bosnia-Herzegovina.)
With regard to radio stations’
programming contents on the Web, we find some very interesting information. In
the profile of radio stations’ programming orientation, the following sections
dominate: culture, sports, entertainment program, cultural contents, commercial
contents, economic issues and politics. By analyzing the programming contents
of radio stations on the Web, we notice that entertainment program dominates.
It is followed by sports, culture and commercial contents. Political contents
are featured to a much lesser degree, and economic issues are convincingly
last.
By searching the Web and analyzing the
Web addresses of Bosnian-Herzegovinian radio stations to be found in the
country and abroad, we singled out the following radio stations which have
their own Web sites.
BH Radio 1 Sarajevo www.rtvbih.ba The pages are visually not
interesting. They contain the following sections: about the radio, program
(program schedule), shows (overview of the most popular shows during the week),
frequencies, and live, where it is possible to follow daily news programs in
real time. These shows are archived every month and users can listen to them.
It does not have any links or the possibility of searching through the archive
by topic.
EFM Radio (Student Radio) Sarajevo www.radioefm.com Design of its pages is
modest. It broadcasts a live program on the Internet.
Independent Radio TNT Travnik www.tnt.radio.ba It broadcasts a live
program 24 hours a day. Its homepage has links to the following sections: news,
marketing, data, links, program. It has a visits counter which shows that the
Web site is visited by many people. It contains links to other radio stations
and to the radio network BORAM
Radio BM (Bosniak/Muslim) Zenica www.bm.radio.ba It features information on
the program and individual shows. It broadcasts a live program.
Radio Dobre Vibracije Mostar http://businessbih.com.rdv Design of the
site is very modest. It only contains basic data on the radio and marketing
contacts.
Radio Siroki Brijeg www.radiosirokibrijeg.com This Web
site only contains e-mail addresses of the employed journalists and radio
station management. In an informative sense, this site means nothing to
potential users.
Radio TNT Travnik www.tnt.radio.ba In addition to basic
information on the radio station in textual form, the site also contains the
regular program schedule and marketing rates. Current news is also featured
textually, but is not updated on weekends. It has links to other media outlets
and organizations in Bosnia-Herzegovina. The radio broadcasts a live program on
the Internet. When it was searched, the site’s counter registered 72,337
visits.
Radio Kakanj www.radio-kakanj.com The whole point of
this Internet site is to establish contact for marketing in the regular
program.
Radio Doboj www.radiodoboj.net This radio program can
be heard live on the Internet and that is all the station’s Web site offers.
Radio M Sarajevo www.radiom.net It broadcasts a live program
on the Internet and it features a selection of current news textually, as well
as information on marketing services.
Radio Station Mir Medjugorje www.medjugorje.hr It broadcasts a live program
on the Internet.
Radio Posusje www.radio-posusje.com Design of the
site is very modest and it does not broadcast its program on the Internet. The
site contains information about the radio station, current news and contacts
for marketing in regular program.
Radio Stari Grad Sarajevo www.rsg.ba This Web site contains only the basic
information on the radio, address and telephone number.
Radio Zid Sarajevo www.cyberzid.com This Web site was created
for young people and it enables its radio program to be heard live.
Organization of its program is divided for all age groups separately.
RTV Grad Sarajevo www.radiograd.delta.com.ba Design
of the site is modest. It contains basic data and contacts for marketing
services in regular program. The possibility of listening to its program on the
Internet is limited to several selected shows from 1997/98 stored in Real audio
format.
RTV Zavidovici www.geocities.com/rockbih/radio-zavidovici.htm
The site is very poorly designed. It does not have a real player for listening
to its program.
NES Radio Banja Luka www.nesbl.tripod.com The site only
contains a program schedule.
Free Radio Prijedor www.freeradio.rs.ba Design of the site
is modest. It broadcasts its program on the Internet.
Radio Feniks Prijedor www.radio-feniks.com Design of the site
is modest. Its program can be followed on the Internet.
RTV Vikom Gradiska www.vicom-company.com The media
organization Vikom has a serious approach to the design and maintenance of its
Web site. Programming broadcast from Vikom’s studios in Derventa, Gradiska and
Banja Luka can be followed live on the Internet. Information is regularly
updated in textual format and is linked to other Web sites of use to visitors.
Srpski Radio Celinac www.inecco.net/src The site is not
completed but it gives the possibility of following its program on the
Internet.
Radio Doboj http://radio.doboj.net This media outlet has
a modest Web site. It contains textual information about this television
company. It broadcasts a live program on the Internet.
JP RT RS Banja Luka www.rtrs-bl.com The site is visually
attractive. It contains textual information on this television company and a
selection of current news. It broadcasts an experimental Internet program.
Radio Q Visoko www.radioq.co.ba The site is not completed.
The offered links are not in function.
RTV Big Banja Luka www.big.banjaluka.net The web site
provides its users with textual information. It does not broadcast on the
Internet.
RTV BN Bijeljina www.rtvbn.rstel.net It features a
textual program schedule and selection of news from the informative program. It
does not broadcast on the Internet.
Radio Mostar www.domovina.net/Radio_Mostar
The radio station has a Web edition on the Domovina Net server. It broadcasts
some programs on the Internet which are archived by date of broadcasting.
Radio Bosanska Krupa http://oasis.fortunecity.com/pyramids/257.radio.htm
Design of this radio station’s Web site is very poor. It features extensive
information about the radio station and marketing with photographs of the
newsroom’s premises.
BORAM Radio Network www.boram.ba This Web site only contains a
table with a list of the radio stations that make up the Boram network.
Closed
Web Addresses
By making a comparison with analyses of
Internet editions of Bosnian-Herzegovinian radio stations carried out over the
past years, we can see that a large number of them are missing. During this
search we encountered the problem of locating the Web addresses of certain
providers. Sometimes a message saying ‘site under development’ or something
similar appeared. In those cases we knew what was happening, unlike in most
situations when we got the message that the address did not exist or the server
was not responding. Then we had to try half an hour later or the next day
because they were temporarily cut off the network or too busy. This kind of
search established that a large number of radio stations on the Internet have
stopped maintaining their Web sites. Among them we will single out the
following:
Radio Slon Tuzla www.slon.tuzla.net The Web site contains
banners of Web design companies. The site is not made in a fashion befitting a
radio station. This is a case of an unprofessional experiment, an effort to be
original and to offer something different, but the result is a site which is
not in function at all. The advertised live audio and video are not
functioning, which deceives the site users.
Radio Kameleon Tuzla www.kameleon.ba It has been shut off the www
until further notice.
Bosnian-Herzegovinian
Radio Stations Abroad
During the war approximately 2.5
million people fled or were displaced from Bosnia-Herzegovina. The Internet
appeared as the fastest link to their homeland. Radio stations broadcasting on
the Internet were created for large groups of emigrants from
Bosnia-Herzegovina. Other mass media from Bosnia-Herzegovina can also be
followed via these sites.
Domovina Net www.domovina.net This is the most important
site for linking people who emigrated from Bosnia-Herzegovina with their
homeland. Design of the Web site makes it possible to listen to several radio
stations and to read a number of print media from Bosnia-Herzegovina.
Radio Most www.radiomost.com This radio station
operates in Denmark. The Web site contains only basic information about the
radio in textual form. It broadcasts a selection of programs of Bosnian-Herzegovinian
radio stations on the Internet once a week.
Radio Novi Milenijum http://novimilenijum.8m.com This is a
radio station for young people from Bosnia-Herzegovina who emigrated to
Denmark.
Radio Dobre Vibracije Denmark www.dobrevibracije.dk/default_small.htm
The content is divided into latest news and archive. The Web site contains
links to Web sites of other mass media, as well as sites with music and other
contents of interest to young people. Contributors from Bosnia-Herzegovina
prepare audio items about concerts that are held, and there are particularly a
lot of interviews with well-known singers. Although the homepage says the content
is updated twice a week, by listening to the items we can see that the last
item is from September 2001. The fact that 63,094 visits were registered at the
moment when this search was carried shows that the Web site was important for
young people from Bosnia-Herzegovina living in Denmark.
Internet
RADIO
It was established in Washington back
in 1994 that the media had contributed to the expansion of the war in
Bosnia-Herzegovina and the Agreement placed them under cantonal control. As
this was not a good solution, all later agreements also dealt with the issue of
media. The 1997 Sintra Declaration gave the High Representative charged with
implementing the civilian aspects of the peace agreement in Bosnia-Herzegovina
complete powers over the media in Bosnia-Herzegovina. The 1997 donor conference
in Bonn requested that new laws be passed on media and telecommunications. In
mid-1998 the High Representative passed a decision to create the Independent
Media Commission (IMC), which completely took control over the media in
Bosnia-Herzegovina. Later, the agency was transformed into the CRA
(Communication Regulatory Agency), which issues licenses for the work of
electronic media. These commissions have often clashed with media outlets over
harsh administrative-judicial procedures, which they claimed were suffocating
their work and creating a psychosis of uncertainty. Therefore, just as we are
astonished by insistence on the fulfillment of high professional standards for
conventional electronic media, we must also express concern by the fact that
radio broadcasting on the Internet is absolutely ignored. Media on the Internet
do not fall under anyone’s jurisdiction. This is incomprehensible in light of
the planetary role of these media.
By searching the Internet, we can find
the following addresses of Internet radios which broadcast in the languages
spoken by the peoples living in Bosnia-Herzegovina.
ISV Radio Sarajevo www.isv.co.ba It broadcasts a live program on
the Internet. This is a Web site for prevention of drug abuse.
BosnaNet Radio, First Bosnian Internet
Radio www.bosnanetradio.com It
broadcasts a live music program on the Internet.
Rok Radio www.modrica.com/bihrock It broadcasts
music on the Internet 24 hours a day. Internet music radio.
BH Sound http://bhsound.8m.com It broadcasts music
contents all day long on the Internet. Contact with visitors was intensified
when the possibility of voting for songs on a music chart was offered.
Radio Mit Modrica www.modrica.com/radio/index2.htm
This is an Internet radio. It is not registered. In addition to programs
produced by this radio, programs by other radio stations can also be followed
on this site.
Internet Radio BLICNET www.blic.net The radio’s program schedule is
featured in textual form so that users can see when certain shows will be
featured. News of the day from the country and abroad is broadcast starting one
minute before the full hour. The source of all news items is the news agency
SRNA. The station has banners.
PRINT MEDIA ON THE WEB
Daily newspaper circulations in the
five most developed countries of the world (United States, Japan, Germany, UK
and France) fell by three to 10 percent in the period from 1992 to 1996.
Bearing in mind that this is the period when the phenomenon of the New Medium
was created and when it experienced mass media affirmation, the reason for the
fall in daily press circulations can partly be attributed to the new trend –
electronic newspapers. The first such electronic daily, without a paper
equivalent, was the Nando Times which
has been on the Web since 1996.
Use and application of the New Medium
in Bosnian-Herzegovinian media can be analyzed from two starting premises:
-
Do journalists
use the New Medium in an optimum way in terms of gathering information?
-
Do journalists
know how to present information in the best way by using the New Medium’s
multimedia quality?
Based on the results of researching
Bosnian-Herzegovinian on-line media, it is evident that Bosnian-Herzegovinian
media usually offer nothing more that the headlines published in equivalent
paper media. This means that they are not using the potentials of the New
Medium.
Journalists and their computer literacy
are one of the fundamental conditions for use of the New Medium and there is no
doubt that journalists will soon experience a major reorganization of the
system brought about by a reorganization of technological infrastructure.
Reorganization of the way journalists
have operated so far will primarily be based on use of the New Medium. Here the
journalist first appears as a supervisor, and then as a creator of Web sites on
the topics he covers. Therefore, the journalist will be expected to have a much
higher degree of know-how, creativity, cooperation and interactivity with
readers than he has had so far. A glance at the Web editions of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian mass media shows that they are created by webmasters and
that separate Web newsrooms do not exist and the responsible individuals are
not listed. Hence, we conclude that this phenomenon in Bosnia-Herzegovina has
not been understood seriously yet.
In the information flow, the journalist
is a link in the chain between sources of news and final users. The journalist
of the 21st century must keep pace with the New Medium since this is
the only way to be able to: access information (input) such as: World Wide Web
via search engines (Altavista, Yahoo, Lycos, Magellan…), documentation: (CD ROM
encyclopedias, electronic archives…), news in the field he covers (specialized
www sites…), referral news from the area he is addressing (from the community
in which the medium operates).
The above premise also affects the
dissemination and presentation of information (output) since this enables:
easier journalistic tasks, reduction of repetitive actions, faster and more
comprehensive access to sources of information, faster access to clients,
creativity in selecting means of expression on the New Medium, and finally,
up-to-date information.
The generally accepted requirements
that must be met in order for a medium to be given the prefix electronic are:
-
editorial
computerization and Internet connection
-
creating an
editorial board for an electronic newspaper
-
adaptation of
headlines from paper to a WWW newspaper
-
adding links
to related contents, databases, pictures, animations
-
expanding
contents with new headlines, as well as readers’ items
-
designing
electronic pages for the WWW
-
creating a
system of page searches by headline, content, context…
-
marking
contents for a database, categorization
-
archiving
-
subscription
and set rates.
Press
in Bosnia-Herzegovina on the Web
Bosnian-Herzegovinian newspapers on the
Internet do not have even the basic characteristics of electronic newspapers.
Generally speaking, they do not have separate editorial boards, they do not
have an easily searched archive, they are not connected by current links to
related contents, they do not have specified headlines and visuality befitting
an electronic edition, etc.
Homepages of Web sites with similar
political and interest views used to be interactive over the past years. Lately
these sites have been redesigned and they lack links to other media, which may
have to do with the departure of people managing the media. Interactivity, as
the main characteristic of Internet media, is also lacking within the media themselves.
Specifically, in organizing archived contents. For, ethics in Internet
journalism is based on organization of ‘expanded contents.’ Hence, on learning
news from information about the cause, reason, main participants in an event,
etc. Bosnian-Herzegovinian media on the Internet lack this dimension although,
based on everything else, it is evident that they have the necessary
capabilities. Therefore, one may conclude that the political circles that
dominate the media in Bosnia-Herzegovina are consciously counting on the
population’s short memory and the impossibility of searching through archives
by topic.
After all, individual analysis of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian press on the WWW clearly shows that a large number of
media which used to have decent design are consciously neglecting their
Internet editions, whilst others have shut them down completely.
DNEVNI AVAZ www.avaz.ba This daily used to feature articles
from its conventional edition in PDF format. The site is now dominated by a
message saying that PDFs will no longer be published. Poorly organized content
is reduced to the following sections: current events, features, interview,
commentary, black chronicle and sports. Each section consists of a single,
unedited article without layout or photographs. Short summaries of the offered
articles on the homepage are not interactive with them. Today the site is only
a remainder of what it used to be, which points to the conclusion that the
owner is trying to boost sales of the paper edition by destroying the Web site.
NEZAVISNE NOVINE BANJA LUKA www.nezavisne.com This site has a good
quality design. Its content is structured in sections. Latest headlines on the
homepage are interactive with integral articles. The Internet edition is much
more abundant than the print edition and it is edited by a separate Nezavisne
Novine Internet team. It has links to other WWW sites and the fact that the
site is profitable is proven by numerous banners and advertisements built into
the site.
DANI Sarajevo www.bhdani.com Web site of the Sarajevo
weekly Dani. The homepage is dominated by headlines of articles from the
wartime period in Sarajevo. The headlines are interactive with integral
articles. Issues are archived as of 1997. New issues are not posted on the
Internet site. The archive is not searchable, the structure is poorly organized
and design of the pages is inadequate. It contains a link to the Internet library
Interliber.
LJILJAN www.nippljiljan.com This Sarajevo weekly
does not feature the content of its latest issue on its Web site. Old issues
are archived by issue, but the search possibility does not function. Poor
design results in low visits. The site registered only 110 visits for the whole
year.
AZRA www.avaz.ba/azra
It only contains several headlines from the issue. There is a message saying
that PDFs will no longer be published.
EXPRESS www.avaz.ba/Express Several selected
headlines are interactive with articles offering further information.
SLOBODNA BOSNA www.slobodna-bosna.ba Design of this
news organization’s Web site is decent. Current topics from the latest issue on
the homepage are interactive with more extensive articles. Issues are archived
as of 2001.
MAGAZINES
MAGAZIN MOBILNI TELEFONI – Internet
edition www.mobilnimagazin.com
This site is a real example of an Internet magazine. It is not a copy of a
paper edition. It is an Internet edition designed following the rules that have
been accepted for the New Medium. What is particularly valuable in the design
is interaction with users. On-line discussions with users are conducted daily
on some 20 or so topics from the field of communications. Users can apply for
the mobile magazine’s Web club membership and receive latest news from this
field on their e-mail addresses.
MAGAZIN ZASTO NE – Web edition www.whynot.com.ba It has a banner. It
covers current events in the field of fashion, fitness, cosmetics, massage,
plastic surgery. The Internet edition is similar to the conventional edition
and articles are archived by topic.
SABAH www.sabah-ba.com
This is a Bosnian-American paper. Readers are the paper’s contributors. It
gathers people from Bosnia living in other countries. Content and basic
information about the content cannot be found on the Internet. Readers are
invited to apply with their details so that the paper can be delivered to their
home addresses. The counter showing the figure of 182,335 visits on the day of
our search shows that the site has a lot of visits.
CLOSED WWW SITES
From a fairly large group of print
media which have shut down their Internet editions, we will single out certain
ones which had exceptionally good design, great significance for users and a
lot of visits to their sites.
BiH AUTOMOTO REVIJA www.pksa.com.ba/auto This used to be the
best designed Web site of all the Bosnian-Herzegovinian media. The site was
designed and maintained by the Sarajevo company Unicorn.
HRVATSKA RIJEC SARAJEVO www.hrvatska-rijec.com This weekly
was characterized by good quality design of its Internet edition. Particularly
valuable were numerous links to other media and public and cultural
organizations. It was last updated on October 29, 2001.
EKSTRA MAGAZIN BIJELJINA www.ekstramagazin.com The high quality
Web design of this newspaper was last updated on February 2, 2001.
NOVO OGLEDALO PRIJEDOR www.prijedor.ba/novo-ogledalo
It also shut down its Web site.
WEB NEWSPAPERS
The term Web newspapers stands only for
electronic editions with specially prepared contents. They do not copy the
contents of a print or audiovisual medium. This is part of electronic
publishing on the Web with contents providing users with a maximum degree of
information and understanding.
Web newspapers have become a source of
information for the young generation because it uses the Internet more. The
structure and content of information influences their opinions, learning and
other processes especially because of the synergic affect of multimedia, links
to related contents, databases, etc. Therefore, the content of Web newspapers
should have recognizable sources of information, publisher and editorial board,
as the main preconditions for credible content. Web newspapers, as one of the
fastest media without a publishing deadline, could improve the structure of
information in the Bosnian-Herzegovinian information space, change the set ways
of the local media and consistently apply the rules of the journalist
profession.
The law does not specify the
obligations of electronic media, although it sets down in detail the working
conditions of traditional media. This shortcoming creates a gray zone for Web
newspapers. If we consider the planetary role of this medium, we should agree
that Web newspapers should be the forerunner of the application of the rules of
the profession and truthfulness of public word. For this reason they should be
separated from the rest of the diverse contents offered in Web space. The
following criteria apply for this purpose:
-
updating
contents at short one-day intervals,
-
publishing
political, economic and other news
-
recognizable
Web address
-
creating
contents on a number of pages and levels.
A detailed analysis of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian WWW newspapers shows the following:
-
they generally
use information from conventional media and publish it with a day’s delay,
which conflicts with the nature of Web newspapers;
-
they have
two-way communication with readers as one of the supreme achievements of the
New Medium;
-
they use the
possibility of interactivity, which is the main characteristic of Web space and
the New Medium. They have overshadowed traditional media on the Web. More open,
public and acceptable media space has been created since the application of
state-of-the-art information technology has enabled not only the application, but
also the production of media;
-
work without a
recognizable editorial board, especially editor-in-chief, and unknown publisher
places these Web newspapers in the area of yellow press.
ANALYSIS OF E-ZINES IN BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA
COSMOPOLIT Bosnian Internet Magazine www.webq.co.uk/cosmopolit Its
content is organized into: columns, news, politics, music, culture, art,
sports, interviews with celebrities.
INFO Power Information e-zine for
collection and presentation of information from various fields www.angelfire.com/mf.infopower
INFO BIH E-zine for Bosnia-Herzegovina
and Una-Sana Canton www.infobih.com It is
updated on a daily basis and contains news from almost all fields: agency news
items, sports with reports on sports events, tables and results, film and music
charts with Real Audio and Real Video Stream, shareware reviews, interesting
news from the Internet world, news from local radio stations in Una-Sana
Canton, etc. It has a large number of links which can be very useful to
visitors.
MAGAZINE BOSNA – BH Internet magazine www.bih.co.ba It covers happenings in the
fields of entertainment, music and sports. It has banners.
MEDJUGORJE PRESS BULLETIN www.medjugorje.org/mpress.htm
Contents are featured in six languages: Croatian, English, French, German,
Italian and Spanish. It is not updated regularly and design of its textual
contents is unacceptable: badly laid out, long and visually unattractive. When
we made the search we saw that the counter was registering 531,394 visits.
During the previous years the site used to be edited by experts from New York
and on April 6, 1999 the site had an exceptionally high number of visits, as
many as 15,280,502. In just three years this is a tremendous number of visits
even for the most important media in the world.
MONITOR MOSTAR www.monitor.ba The site is maintained by the
company Infonet. It has a decent design and can serve as an example of how to
make a good quality WWW newspaper. Information is updated more than once every
24 hours. It is of note that information appears on this WWW site before it
appears in daily newspapers or electronic media. The homepage contains current
news linked to more extensive reports. It has a news archive and the search is
well organized. Authors of articles and the site founder are not identified,
which needlessly places it among ‘yellow’ press. Still, the site has many
visitors, 457,389 when this analysis was made. The site is enriched by a photo
gallery with pictures of all places in Bosnia-Herzegovina known for their natural
attractions. Contact with users is established via chats on current issues.
Financial profitability of the site is presumably guaranteed by banners of all
of the more important companies in Herzegovina.
MEDIA ON-LINE SARAJEVO www.mediaonline.ba Magazine on the media
in South East Europe. It features bilingual content, in English and in the
languages spoken by the peoples living in Bosnia-Herzegovina. Headlines from
the new edition and latest information from the homepage are linked to integral
articles. Articles can be chosen in html or pdf format. The magazine’s archive
is an example of good organization of information on the Internet. It is
archived by issue and topic. Information can be searched by keyword or by name
of author. Easy communication is possible with the magazine’s editors.
NEWS AGENCIES ON THE INTERNET
SENSE AGENCY – South East News Service
Europe www.sense-agency.com This is
a specialized news agency offering daily news on activities of the
international community and their impact on the countries of the former
Yugoslavia. It contains a phono recording of SENSE agency reports and analysis
of the day. Trials taking place at The Hague-based War Crimes Tribunal are
broadcast live via Real Video. Polls, forums and chat enable two-way
communication with users. Audio and video news is archived and can be searched.
The news service is searchable by keyword as well. It is also possible to
search the SENSE archive, as well as the entire Web.
ONASA – Independent News Agency www.onasa.ba This Sarajevo-based news agency
has four news services: all news, general service, business service and NGO and
political party info in Bosnian and English. Short news is interactive with
general news, which is available to all users. More detailed information on
these events is separately organized for subscribers. This kind of organization
of content has resulted in a lot of visits to the Web site. From October 1,
1999 to April 17, 2002 the site was visited by 298,777 users.
HABENA www.habena.ba
The site is very poor in information. Contents are structured into three
services: politics, economy and sports. It is evident that this task is not
approached seriously. During the search we came upon news items with old dates,
which is absurd and inadmissible for a news agency.
SRNA BANJA LUKA www.srna.co.yu This news agency produces six
services for radio and television stations, daily and weekly newspapers: daily
service, news review, service for culture and human interest pieces, selection
of news in English, service for sports news and human interest pieces, service
for articles on science and arts, special service and photo service.
Interaction leads us to a description of services, but news cannot be followed
because links to the services do not function.
CLOSING
REMARKS ON WEB MEDIA IN BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA
Information
technology has strongly shaken the way mass media have been organized up until
now. In the post-war years we witnessed a steady growth of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian media with WWW sites, but over the past year or two we
witnessed their closure. As for media that are still maintaining their Internet
sites, unfortunately we cannot see them fully using the potentials offered by
the New Medium, although Network permeability has increased several times since
the first attempts, which has made even complex projects available along the
axle user-medium-hypermultimedia.
By using the advantages of the New
Medium, creativity of the person who is designing an electronic medium becomes
one of the most important success factors of that medium. Rapid growth of
e-zines indicates an increasing number of creative amateurs who are trying to
publish their own electronic magazines. Web editions of conventional media
still do not differ sufficiently from their equivalents.
The local journalist community is not
accepting the New Medium because it is convinced that investment in the
Internet does not pay off. This is seen more as a promotional activity rather
than a new form of publishing. Media organizations’ managements are not ready
to establish editorial boards for electronic newspapers. Analysis of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian media on the WWW has shown that they are not using the
Web by putting its advantages to the best use. The main objection regarding
this issue could be that not all of the potentials of synergy between
hypermediality and multimedia are used on the WWW sites of
Bosnian-Herzegovinian online media.
This challenges the rationality of
using the electronic medium since its role is reduced to copying the original
medium. Such WWW sites end up being closed very soon for two reasons: data is
not updated, which reduces users’ interest, and financial support is lacking.
Marija
Putica teaches Information Science at the Journalism
Studies of the University of Mostar, Bosnia-Herzegovina, and is a permanent
contributor to Media Plan Institute. ©Media Online 2002. All rights reserved.